Showing posts with label souls. Show all posts
Showing posts with label souls. Show all posts

Are Emotions Spiritual?


The simple answer is no, emotions are not a faculty of the soul. 

I am not an expert on emotions. What I do know is that emotions are a physical phenomenon, often triggered by an experience or a memory. They do not have a spiritual nature.

However, the emotions can act as a bridge to the spirit, just as our mind can act as a bridge to our intellect and our 'heart' as a bridge to our will. These are not easily discernable distinctions.

Our soul, our spiritual nature, consists of intellect and will. This is what it means to be created in God’s image. Our human intellect and will are immortal and created to know, love, and serve God forever.


Yet, it is impossible to speak about our human nature without understanding ourselves as embodied persons. We are flesh and blood, and not pure spirit. We are composite beings: spirit and flesh. Death rends asunder what is integral to our human nature.

So, what does this have to do with essential oils?

Because essential oils can chemically and even electrically effect our emotions, oils can be used to balance or support our emotional health. Clement of Alexandria said aromatic oils should be used for depression, for example.

That is straight forward. The oils support our emotional wellbeing, we feel grateful and happy, and consequently our will may be more disposed to do good and avoid evil, especially if the good is being patient with your two-year-old, and the evil is sending the child away to daycare so you can have some me-time.

So, what is the problem?

The problem is in the articulation of how oils interact with our emotions and our spirit. If one does not have a sound philosophical understanding of the human person and the nature of created things, like plants and their essential oils, then essential oils can be made to sound like magic potions or agents of superstition.

This tragically leads people to disregard the use of essential oils altogether, which is not what God intended.

Let’s say Joe has not had any training in Thomistic philosophy. He is a child of his times and has been exposed to widespread New Age philosophy.  

Joe has heard that essential oils have a frequency (true) and that that means they have a spiritual nature (not true) and that if he smells a particular blend of oils, he will be able to dream big dreams about his future and make his dream come true simply by smelling this oil. (That is called superstition, a sin against the 1st Commandment.)

There are several false assumptions in Joe’s line of thinking. First, Joe falsely assumes the frequency of essential oils is of a spiritual nature. It is not. Electricity is measurable, it is finite. It is not spiritual.

The oils may inspire him to dream big and he may even see his dreams come about, but Joe’s free will would be the agent that brought this dream to reality, not the oil blend. The oil may have given him an emotional boost – momentary motivation to pursue his dream - but in the end, his acts of the will, in cooperation with or against the will of God, would make his dream come true, or not.

So, the oils worked, right? Yes, the oils do what they do, they support the emotions, but beyond that, one must acknowledge the activity of our intellect and free-will as agents of good or evil – not the oils.

Essential oils are what God created them to be. Our belief about them cannot change their nature. They are morally neutral. If I use essential oils to calm my nerves before I rob a bank. The oils have not been bad, I have been bad. On the other hand, if I use essential oils to help my crying baby fall asleep, everyone is happy and I am a hero, not the oils.

If this post was helpful, feel free to leave a comment below and please share the post with a friend. Thank you!

"Nature's Living Energy": How is God Present in His Creation?

O Heavenly King, Comforter, Spirit of Truth,
Who art everywhere present and fillest all things,
Treasury of blessing and Giver of life,
Come and abide among us
and in Thy goodness, save our souls.
                     - “usual beginning” of the Greek Christian rites


Nature’s Living Energy

Someone asked me once, “What do people mean that say essential oils are ‘nature’s living energy’?” I avoided a direct answer because I didn’t know what was meant by that. But, recently I was reading, Physica, by Hildegard von Bingen (1098-1179 A.D.) and her text shed some light on this concept. Hildegard was recently recognized as a 'Doctor of the Church' by Pope Benedict XVI, (which, by the way, has raised a few eyebrows among orthodox Catholics because some of her writings are rather unusual.) 

   My purpose in introducing Hildegard, however, is not to raise controversy but to look at a Christian Theologian, poet, and herb master of the medieval world who has something very interesting to add to our conversation. Some New Agers have tried to claim Hildegard as ‘one of their own’, but Hildegard ought to be interpreted within the context of her own Christian tradition. She is ‘one of our people.’

   Hildegard, like the monks and nuns of her day, were not only prayer warriors and farmers, but scholars and doctors, as well. The medieval monastery always had an herb garden. Monastics were the most highly educated men and women of their time and they would have kept the wisdom of the ages regarding medicine in addition to the other human sciences.


   In Physica, Hildegard discusses the medicinal qualities of various plants, animals, and minerals. 

I found Hildegard’s "Introduction to Plants" wise and practical:

With earth was the human being created. All the elements served mankind and sensing that man was alive, they busied themselves in aiding his life in every way. And man in turn occupied himself with them. The earth gave its vital energy, according to each person’s race, nature, habits, and environment.

   Assuming this is a good translation of Hildegard, from German dialect into Latin into English, let’s look at what Hildegard is saying, because her statements are very interesting for our case study in essential oils. This statement, “the earth gave its vital energy” is similar to the “nature’s living energy” quote earlier . . . but one thing at a time.

   First, she acknowledges the hierarchy of God’s creation and the interdependence of creatures. Our tradition confirms our human experience: We depend upon plants and they depend on us. Without each other we could not exist. We give them carbon dioxide, they give us oxygen. All creatures complete and serve each other according to God’s design.

   Then Hildegard speaks as if the elements have intelligence and free-will which enable the elements to volitionally “busy themselves in aiding [man’s] life in every way.” I have heard aromatherapists make claims that sound similar to this – that essential oils know where the body needs them to go, or that the oils only attack bad bacteria, but leave the good bacteria alone.


   Do Essential Oils Have Intelligence?

   There is a principle in classical philosophy that says, “a thing is received (known) according to the nature of the receiver.” Humans are gifted by God with the capacity to know and understand so much more than the other creatures. Humans can apply calculus to engineering, learn multiple languages, study history, and understand themselves philosophically. {Warning: The next few paragraphs are very philosophical. Feel free to read the bold and skip to the next section.}

   In the example of a pet dog looking at a pond this means the animal knows water as something useful to drink or swim in, but a human, because of his rational nature, can receive the idea of water into the intellect and contemplate water both poetically and scientifically. Just as we looked at the sensitive powers of the soul, it is useful to quickly look at the different ways material beings know according to their nature:

   To better understand how plants ‘know’ we must first look at how lifeless bodies (minerals) communicate. By contrasting the ways that minerals and plants know, as Aquinas understood ‘knowing’, we will better understand the powers and limitations of plants. Water communicates with rocks, for example, as it flows over them and around them - pulled downstream by gravity. This communicating between water and rocks is restricted to immediate physical contact. It is literally what we call superficial communication. A pail receives sand; the stream bed receives water, but no mineral changes substantially in the process of knowing another mineral. If the communication becomes more intimate, as in the union of hydrogen and oxygen, the mineral molecules lose their identity and become something else – in this case, water.

   Plants have a richer nature than lifeless minerals. Plants can take on minerals and light from the elements and make them their own without losing their plant identity. But because trees and plants can’t get up and walk around like the animals, their ‘knowing’ is limited to direct physical contact. Animals, on the other hand, know things in immediate relationship but also at a distance so they are vastly superior to plants and minerals, but they are limited by their senses. They are submerged in a sea of feelings and instincts (i.e. they lack reason to sort through their feelings).

   Only man’s soul is able to transcend the limitations of physical existence and know things as universals. 

   Only man can chose between good or bad, because only he can make that judgement. We will study this in depth in the next section, so let’s get back to Hildegard. What could she be saying?

   Do plants or their oils have intelligence to rationally discern such things on their own?! 
No; it is not in the nature of plants (or plant oil) to be rational. So what does Hildegard mean? She must be referring to God’s intelligent presence in creation.

   Considering Hildegard is an orthodox Christian and a highly educated Doctor of the Church, let’s start by eliminating two things she cannot be saying. She is obviously not a Deist. Deism is the belief that God put all of creation in motion and then disengaged and had no more to do with it, like a clockmaker who engineers his clock with gears and gadgets and then winds it up and lets it run, without interfering. 

   Hildegard is also not a pantheist or even a panentheist. New Agers would like to think she is, but she isn’t. She can’t be a pantheist or a panentheist because those ideas are not compatible with orthodox Christianity. We have already looked at pantheism, but a look at panentheism would be very helpful at this point.

   Panentheism is the belief that the Divine interpenetrates every part of nature – that creation is ‘part of’ God. Literally the Greek means, “all-in-God.” We have demonstrated that the Godhead is distinct from His creation, so this cannot be the answer, either, unless panentheism means something other than the essence of God literally present in creation. So in what way is God present in His creation?

   God’s Energies – Divine Grace
   Basil of Cappadocia (330-379 A.D.), Father of the Church, taught that we experience God in His energies, not His essence. Creation is not wholly separated from God, because creation exists in and from the divine energies. The divine energies are the natural way in which God interacts with his creatures. They are the operations and works of God and, in some sense, they are identifiable with God, but creation is completely distinct from God’s essence. Divine energy is also called ‘grace’ – a more familiar term.

   God’s energies are like sunlight. The sun’s energy is the part of the sun we experience – the part that does the work for us on earth, but the rays of the sun are not the sun itself. The analogy is incomplete, because God is not created light (God can be rightly described as uncreated light). Nevertheless, the sun is often used in Christian tradition as a symbol of God, so it is fitting. God is fully present in His energies, but man only participates in communion with God according to his capacity; like Jesus transfigured on Mt. Tabor who showed His glory to His disciples as far as they were able to bear it.

   We cannot know the depths of divine essence, but we can experience the energies of God. The transcendent nature of God is independent of creation and yet, the Apostle Paul tells us, “Ever since the creation of the world His invisible nature, namely, His eternal power and His deity, has been clearly perceived in the things that have been made.” (Romans 1:20). Out of love for us, God creates the universe, by His will and from His energies. All of creation is alive to God and God’s graces are present in everything.



   We comprehend the ease by which the devil was able to deceive the ancient pagans into nature worship, mistaking the creature for the Creator. God’s working presence in the flowers, trees, waterfalls, and rocks demand a response from us. All of creation, pulsating with divine energy, demands that we love and worship God and God alone, who is in all and for all and works through all. But God honors our free-will and our imperfect intellect. In our misguided attachments to foolishness and selfishness, we often fail to meet God, even though He is all around us.

   Basil reminds us “He shares His energy in ‘proportion to faith’ (Romans 1:16).” Those who commune with God “enjoy Him to the extent that their nature allows, not to the extent that His power allows.” (Basil, On the Holy Spirit) This means, He is present in creation, sustaining and providing for all things, whether we recognize Him or not, but He is not present in a way that we can capture Him and bottle His power up to use according to our plans and devises. He is beyond our grasp. His energies, rather, invite us to recognize His intelligent design and plan – to give glory, honor, and worship where it is do.
PRINCIPLE: GOD IS PRESENT IN ALL OF HIS CREATURES THROUGH HIS DIVINE ENERGIES, WHERE WE ENCOUNTER HIM ACCORDING TO OUR NATURE AND OUR FAITH


   So we return to Hildegard who says, “The earth gave its vital energy, according to each person’s race, nature, habits, and environment.” What does Hildegard mean?


   God Wills the Interdependence of Creatures

   For essential oil users, Hildegard means that God sustains our life through creation, and particularly plants. We can’t live without food and water – elements of the earth. God, in His wisdom created a variety of foods and herbs so that man and beast might be sustained in their diverse habitats – cold or hot, arid or fertile. This is one of the primary ways God manifests Himself to us daily, by providing for our health and nourishment.

   As Basil demonstrates, God is inaccessible and hidden in His essence but He continually bursts forth from hiding in immanent processions (energies), which communicate Himself to creation and through creation. All of creation falls into a hierarchy according to each member’s degree of participation in the Divine plan.

   God wills the interdependence of creatures: The earth is designed by God to run on His energies, but the building blocks of all visible creation - living and non-living – are the atoms and minerals, the raw material. The plants, according to their created nature, take those minerals and transform them, through the help of the sun and the rain, into food and oxygen that nourish animals and humans. Animals play their part, likewise, according to God’s wisdom; and in all of God’s creatures, man encounters the energies of God - at work for his well-being and his life. So that, even in the simple acts of breathing and eating, we might know that God loves and cares for our every need and desires to be near us.

   So, are essential oils "nature's living energy"? It depends what you mean by that. A positive Christian interpretation would be that, all of creation is alive with the presence of God (Divine energies). Essential oils are a gift from God who intelligently designed the oils to benefit our bodies. (That is where oils get their intelligence.) When we use oils according to God's design and purpose, we receive from His bounty the chemical energy (food/nourishment) necessary for life. The measure we encounter God's grace through food or oil (or any other created thing) is in proportion to our faith.

   Isn’t the truth so much more interesting and liberating than the twisted muddle of misconceived assumptions?! Our Christian duty is to align our views with philosophical truth and Christian revelation. You might have anticipated that reading this post would be an unexciting, backward chore. Maybe you still think that and if you do, I hope I have, at least, begun to demonstrate that the discovery of truth is an adventure. For the faithful Christian the adventure comprises of eternal loving relationship with Jesus, the Lord of all Ages, together with Our Heavenly Father, through the Holy, Life-creating Spirit! 

  We are really just getting started, but before we continue, it is fitting that we pause to worship God, Our Creator, echoing the words Francis of Assisi (1181-1226 A.D.) left us, who exclaimed:

May You be praised, O Lord, in all Your creatures, especially brother sun, by whom You give us light for the day; he is beautiful, radiating great splendor, and offering us a symbol of You, the Most High . . .
May You be praised, my Lord, for sister water, who is very useful and humble, precious and chaste . . .
May You be praised, my Lord, for sister earth, our mother, who bears and feeds us, and produces the variety of fruits and dappled flowers and grasses . . .
Praise and bless my Lord, give thanks and serve Him in all humility.
                                                            – from “Canticle of the Creatures”
 If this post has been helpful, thank you for sharing it with others using the share buttons below! We also invite you to LIKE "A Christian's Guide to Essential Oils" on Facebook and follow us there.

Essential Oils: Animal, Vegetable, or Mineral . . . or Divine?!?

I recently took a hike with my son and as we came out of the woods into a wetlands area overlooking a large pond, a wooden deck with a railing came into view. A few steps brought one up to the platform which hosted a pleasant picture of the marsh above the aquatic grass tops. On the deck we observed a gray haired man standing next to a slightly younger, female counter-part. They were both holding lap dogs in their arms, as a mother would hold a child up to a water-faucet, only they were obviously perched so as to be able to enjoy the view. As the couple stood there, talking to their pets, I couldn’t suppress a chuckle, as I recalled a lesson from C.S. Lewis.


   “Are You My Mother?”
   Lewis begins the Abolition of Man with the story of “Coleridge at the Waterfall” in which there are two men, one who admires the waterfall and calls it ‘sublime’; the other who calls it ‘pretty’. One of Lewis’ points is that modern man thinks these are statements of feeling, when they are actually statements of value. The first man says, “This is sublime” because he is making a judgement about the waterfall. His feelings of awe and humility are in response to something intrinsically, profoundly beautiful in the waterfall. The other man is heedless of the waterfall and misses the opportunity to respond reasonably to the falls.

   My observation here is that it takes a human to recognize the goodness and beauty of a sublime landscape. Our pets, I am sorry to say, cannot do it. Contemplating an exquisite masterpiece is the work of the intellect - a gift God gave to humans and angels alone.  It is not in the nature of animals to make a universal, abstract judgement like this. The rational human soul is able to recognize universal goodness. A dog’s soul cannot. Thus, we are faced with the absurdity of the aquatic scene, wherein the owners of the pets assume their animal friends are gifted with capacities they do not possess.

   The behavior of the couple by the pond may be an innocent projection of their own human nature onto their canine companions but we see a lot of projection these days and a general confusion about the nature of all creatures, not just animals. Some confused modern thinkers, for example, treat people like computers, computers like people, and themselves like gods. Others believe they are mere animals or embodied angels.

  What Genesis Reveals: God Gave Humans Dominion over the Material World

The first story of Genesis tells us that God created the universe according to His intelligent design. He established it in order with boundaries and limits, says Psalm 148, which cannot be passed. The six day creation account teaches us about the inner nature, the value, and the ordering of the whole of creation. God separates light from darkness, water from land, plants from animals, and animals from humans.

   “And God saw that it was good.” Augustine reminds us that there is nothing that exists, material or spiritual, that was not created by God and everything is held in existence by the Creator. (Augustine, On Genesis) God's visible, material creatures are endowed with stability and truth according to the order that governs them. In its own particular way, each creature reflects a ray of God’s infinite wisdom, perfect design, and goodness. Because of this goodness, man – made in God’s image and likeness with a rational, spiritual nature and set apart for the task of dominion over the earth (Gen 1:26-29) – ought to respect and steward all of creation according to God’s order and purpose.

   In plain English this means, man must neither selfishly exploit nor devalue the goods of creation nor promote the orders of nature beyond their particular values. The disordered use of creation causes serious problems for humans and their environment.

   God’s Word reveals an ascending scale of value in the order of creation itself. It is expressed in the six days of creation, the order of things being created from less perfect nature to more perfect. God loves all of His creatures. “His compassion is over all He Has made.” (Psalm 145:9) Yet, men and women are clearly the summit of God’s creation. Jesus confirmed the hierarchy of man over animals when He said, “Of how much more value is a man than a sheep!” (Matt. 12:12) And also, “you are of more value than many sparrows.” (Luke 12:7)

   God’s Created Hierarchy in Nature: We Are not Equal to God or Plants

   The hierarchy of nature was expressed in our Western tradition most clearly by the Greek philosopher, Aristotle (384-322 B.C.), and his medieval student, Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274 A.D.), a Dominican friar and ‘Doctor of the Church’. Their understanding of nature is not exhaustive, but, their combined metaphysics is the most coherent study of the order of being in the Western tradition. Even a Western atheist should not ignore it.  As Christopher Dawson (1889-1970 A.D.), the great philosopher of history at Yale claimed - if you do not understand your own tradition first, you can never pretend to understand any other tradition.


   The hierarchy of creation (see chart), in ascending order, is: minerals, plants, animals, humans, angels, and God. That is fairly straight-forward, as is the fact that the nature of minerals, plants, and animals is material and the nature of God and angels is spiritual. Man is more complex because he alone of all creation is both material and spiritual in his nature. We will look at humans another time. For now, let’s look at the powers (scope of functions) God gave to plants and animals because that will help us understand the differing values within the various orders of creation.

   Aristotle and Aquinas recognized that all living bodies (i.e. plants, animals, and humans) have a soul. A soul is the part of a living creature which gives it the capacity to engage in the activities proper to that living organism, according to God’s design. The souls of plants and animals are material souls, not spiritual souls. Only the human soul is spiritual. (Angels don’t have souls because they don’t have bodies). Spiritual beings are rational, which is to say they act with intelligence and free choice.

PRINCIPLE: PLANT (AND ANIMAL) SOULS ARE MATERIAL,
NOT SPIRITUAL, AND THEREFORE NOT RATIONAL


   Plant Souls

   Aristotle and Aquinas call the plant soul a vegetative soul. The vegetative soul has three functions (powers): augmentative, nutritive, and reproductive. These powers enable the plant to draw nutrients from the air and the earth, convert sunlight into energy, grow according to its design, and reproduce according to its kind.

   Practically speaking, essential oils, then, are oils that have developed in the plant, according to God’s design, for the wellbeing of the plant and for the wellbeing of those animals or humans who may partake of the plant for food, medicine, or other needs.

   (The animal soul and the human soul also have vegetative powers which give them the capacity to use food and water, grow, and reproduce according to God’s design.)

   Animal Souls

   Our two philosophers call animal souls, ‘sensitive souls’, not because you can hurt their feelings, but because they act upon their external and internal senses. The external senses are the five we know so well: touch, taste, smell, hearing, and sight. I don’t need to explain. The internal senses are the mysterious ones: memory, imagination, estimation, and apprehending (unifying sense).

   For example, if a dog apprehends that eating steak gives him pleasure, he will store an image of steak in his memory and use his external senses (smell, sight, etc.) to discover more steak in the future. Instincts are proper to the estimating power and allow an animal to apprehend intentions that are not perceived with the external senses. A sheep runs away from a wolf, not because of its color or shape but because instinct ‘tells’ the sheep it is in danger of being eaten. Likewise, a bird gathers straw for a nest, not because it finds the straw pleasant but because instinct instructs the bird that this is good building material. In other words, instinct informs the animal whether something is harmful or useful. Animals (and humans) also have appetitive powers (also called desires, feelings, emotions and passions), but we will look at those later.

   Human Souls

   In addition to these vegetative and animal powers, man’s soul has rational powers. This is to say that, just as animal souls enjoy the vegetative and sensitive powers, man enjoys all three. The powers of intellect and free-will are spiritual powers and belong to the human soul alone. The intellect and will enable the soul to reason and to know and love God and other persons. Angels are also persons, with an intellect and will, but angels do not have a soul because they are pure spirit. The soul, by definition, is the vitalizing principle which enables a plant, animal, or human to perform the activities which we associate with being alive.

   “Where are you going with all this?” you might ask.

   The whole point of going through the hierarchy of creation is to lay a foundation for further sections. The big take away is this: God created plants for a purpose. We honor that purpose by honoring their nature. It does us no good to add or subtract from the value God gave to plants. This kind of adding and subtracting leads to problems that I will try to illuminate in further discussions. For now, be at peace in the wisdom of God’s design for plants and animals. The reality is far more interesting than the half-truths and illusions.

 If this post has been helpful, thank you for sharing it with others using the share buttons below! We also invite you to LIKE "A Christian's Guide to Essential Oils" on Facebook and follow us there.